Tuesday, 25 October 2016

Rigged Elections- 2016 Isn't One Of Them...

As his campaign continues its descent into chaos, Donald Trump has found a new outlet for his anger. He has begun to increasingly blame his impending loss on the 'rigged election.' Usually, the media, or 'Crooked Hillary' Clinton is to blame. But nonetheless, Trump seems determined to paint his failure as the fault of the system.

For all it's faults, the United States of America is the strongest democratic country in the world. Not for nothing does the President still carry the unofficial title 'Leader of the Free World.' So accusations of rigged elections are dangerous. It allows those around the world who are not democrats (small d...) to justify their actions.

The thing is, America has faced problematic elections in the past.

1876

The US Civil War cast a long shadow over the country. Fought between Northern and Southern states over the twin issues of slavery and states' rights, the defeat of the Confederacy led to a period called Reconstruction. The Southern, overwhelmingly Democratic states were garrisoned by the US Army, who also supervised elections, making sure that they were held in accordance with the new laws that banned slavery and discrimination. This led to the election of mainly Republican politicians, including blacks, to governerships, the House and the Senate. Not surprisingly, Southern Democrats hated this policy.

Then came the election of 1876. There were a series of brutal confrontations and intimidations between supporters of both parties. The election went down to the wire. As the results came in, it was clear that the Democrat, Northerner Samuel Tilden, had polled more votes. Indeed, he had taken over half the votes cast, and was one electoral vote short of outright victory. But the results in three states, Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina, were in doubt. Tilden appeared to be ahead of the Republican, Rutherford Hayes, but no one could be sure. As the date for the new president to take office got closer, no solution had been reached.

Until a specially appointed Electoral Commission found that the three states had been won by Hayes. By a single electoral vote, and with a majority of Americans preferring Tilden, Hayes was elected to the presidency. There has been speculation that a deal was struck; the Republicans could keep the White House, but in return federal troops were to be withdrawn from the South. The troops did leave, and the protection they offered to blacks left with them. Reconstruction was ended, possibly thanks to a rigged election. The freed slaves were to suffer dearly during the next century.

Tilden: "Boo Hoo! Ruthy Hayes's got my presidency, and won't give it to me" 1876

1960

1960 is the first potentially rigged election to feature a well-known American political villain. But, for a change, in 1960 the election appears to have been rigged *against* Richard Nixon. The election had been close; no US election has ever been closer.

As the dust settled on the victory for John F Kennedy, the accusations started to fly. The era of political machines was almost over, but not quite. Kennedy had won two states by very narrow margins. His victory in Texas was attributed to the political machine of his vice-presidential candidate, Lyndon B Johnson. There were examples given of counties in Texas were 6000 people had voted, out of 4000 inhabitants.

But even more controversial was the situation in Illinois. Nixon had carried Illinois outside of the city of Chicago. But in Chicago, the political power of the mayor, Richard Daley, delivered the city, the state and the election to Kennedy. Even more sinister, there were accusations swirling that the Kennedy family had asked the mafia to sort out the election in Illinois, in return for the protection of their interests.

Nothing was ever proved in either case. But it is quite possible that one of the giants of American politics became president due to fraud.

John and Bobby Kennedy listening to election night returns, 1960

1968

No electoral fraud here, but possibly something even worse. In 1968, one issue dominated America. The war in Vietnam was turning into a slaughterhouse, with no sign of victory in sight. The war had already forced the sitting president, Lyndon Johnson, to withdraw from the race, as the Democratic party began to collapse amidst the conflict between pro and anti-war factions. The other crisis for the Democrats was that the old Solid South was backing racialist George Wallace of Alabama, rather than official nominee Hubert Humphrey.

Amazingly, despite the near death experience of the Democrats, Humphrey drew level with Richard Nixon, the Republican nominee again after six years in the wilderness. As November approached, it was neck and neck.

As this election was ongoing, there was another drama ongoing. In Paris, the peace negotiators were trying to hammer out a deal between North and South Vietnam. Johnson didn't want his presidency to end in failure, and knew a peace deal would boost Humphrey. The weekend before voting, Johnson called off the American bombing of North Vietnam, and outlined the deal that was about to be agreed.

Nixon panicked. In fact, he panicked so much, that he sent a message to the South Vietnamese, telling them that they would get better terms under a Nixon administration, and so they should reject the deal Johnson had offered. This they duly did. Johnson was livid, telling advisers that Nixon had blood on his hands. But as Johnson had learnt of Nixon's treachery by illegal phone taps, he was unable to reveal what he had done. And so Nixon won the presidency, by the skin of his teeth. Had the American public known he was prepared to sacrifice American lives to do so, they may not have been as willing to vote him in.

Nixon was the one in 1968, but only would he been had people known he'd prolonged a war to win?

1972

Normally, elections are rigged to make sure the 'right person' wins, or to turn a close race into a landslide. By this definition, it is a mystery why on Earth Richard Nixon felt the need to tamper with the 1972 campaign. The Democrats had selected George McGovern as their candidate, who was way to the left of what American opinion would accept. And this proved to be the case. Nixon hammered McGovern, 61% to 38%. Only Massachusetts voted for McGovern; the other 49 states went for Nixon.

This would probably have happened anyway. But there had been some strange events along the way. The campaign of prominent senator Edmund Muskie had collapsed, after he was accused of insulting French-Canadians, and rumours swirled that his wife was an alcoholic. Muskie was forced out of the race, and the road for McGovern was clearer. Then, problems beset the campaign. Problems such as rallies being cancelled, or double booked. Leaflets going missing. Insulting leaflets being handed out. Low level disruption.

And then one night, some burglars were caught in the headquarters of the Democratic National Committee, at the Watergate Hotel. Even as Nixon cruised to victory, in an election he would have won anyway, his efforts to frustrate his opponents were already being revealed. It would prove to be his downfall.

2000

The most obvious example that jumps to mind is the bitter experience of 2000. Al Gore and George W Bush were deadlocked in the Electoral College, although Gore had a clear edge in the popular vote. The state of Florida was close. In fact, it was so close that no one could establish who had actually won. The entire election process was thrown into chaos, as rows erupted over whether the voting machines were faulty, the best method to recount the votes, and whether the ballot papers had been marked correctly. It seems unlikely that thousands of Jewish voters opted for the ultra-conservative Christian firebrand Pat Buchanan, yet that is what their ballot papers seemed to say afterwards.

But this was not fraud, this was farce. The fraud came from the way that the aftermath was handled. The governor of the state is ultimately responsible for elections in their state. In Florida, in 2000, this was George W Bush's younger brother. The person who had the authority to declare and certify the winner was the chair of Bush's Florida campaign team. They did their best to disrupt and frustrate the process at every single stage. The arguments in the courts were designed to keep Bush as the winner, and not to determine the actual winner in the state of Florida. The Democrats presumed FairPlay, and so brought a knife to a gun fight.

Had a full recount been permitted in Florida, across the entire state, it is entirely possible that Al Gore would have emerged the victor. He may not have done either. That is fine. But what happened was not fair. It was what the Bush campaign wanted, and it happened they controlled enough positions in Florida to make it so.

Newsweek reflects the question of the American people, 2000

Why 2016 won't make this list

Compared to the examples, 2016 is unlikely to be remembered as a rigged election. With the exception of 1972 (when God knows what Richard Nixon was on), all of the examples cited above were razor edge close. Because the USA weights the votes of each state in the Electoral College, a close race can be decided by a handful of voters in one or two states. Had Gore been treated fairly in 2000 in Florida, a victory there would have put him over the winning line. Had the commission in 1876 worked out which states had voted for which candidate, Tilden may well have been elected, regardless of any secret deal. A shift of a few thousand votes would have seen a president Nixon in 1961, or a president Humphrey in 1969.

But Trump is not shaping up for a close race. If current polling is anything to go by, he is going to lose to Hillary Clinton by a solid margin, and her lead keeps growing as election day gets nearer. The previous experience of American elections is that, when one person is winning by a landslide, then it's because they are winning by a landslide. It's when it gets close that the chances of a suspicious result rise.

There's also the mechanics of how American elections work, sate by state. The Republican party controls most state-level posts in America, including many of the ones who organise and certify election results. Not only would every single Democrat have to be in on the conspiracy, but a fair chunk of Republican America would have to be involved in depriving their own nominee of the prize. Many Republican officials may not like Trump, but that claim is outlandish. There's no great love for the Clintons amongst the GOP.

There are many reasons Trump will lose this election. But a vast meta-conspiracy to rig the election isn't one of them.

Tuesday, 18 October 2016

The Conquest You Won't Have Heard Of

A few days ago marked the 950th anniversary of the Battle of Hastings, when the Anglo-Saxon world came crashing down in the face of Duke William the Bastard. The Norman Conquest would sweep their world away.

Often forgotten is that the Anglo-Saxons were very, very lucky. They had got a second chance. For today marks one thousand years since the other Conquest of England in the eleventh century.

It's fair to say that the reign of Aethelred II of England was fraught with difficulty. Harried by Viking attacks for much of his reign, by 1014 he had been deposed, hiding in exile in Normandy. The Viking king, Swein Forkbeard, was due to be crowned. Then, at the start of 1015, Aethelred was saved. Swein died, and the Anglo-Saxon Witan invited their former king back. But Aethelred was living on borrowed time. Swein's son, Cnut*, returned with a vengeance. By April 1016, Aethelred was besieged in London. And then he died, on St George's day. Much of the country was under Cnut's control. The ancient line of kings, stretching back into the mists of the post-Roman world, had apparently come to an end.

Enter Aethelred's son. Edmund Ironside was proclaimed king by those in London. His first move was to leave the city, and return to his ancestral homeland of Wessex. Here, he raised the West Saxon fyrd, and prevented the Vikings from further advances. Edmund then returned to London, and at the Battle of Brentford he lifted the Viking siege of the city. After years of royal dithering and inactivity, finally the Anglo-Saxons were putting up a fight.

Cnut's forces fell back into Essex, pursued by Edmund and the Anglo-Saxons. On October 18th, 1016, Edmund overtook Cnut at the battle of Assandun. Here was his chance to rid England of the Danes once and for all.

But it never happened. Desperate for allies, Edmund was relying on the Mercian Ealdorman Eadric Streona,  to assist him. But Eadric had a reputation for treachery, and this time was no different. During the battle, he switched to supporting Cnut, and the Anglo-Saxons were defeated.

Both sides were exhausted. Cnut had been unable to deliver the knockout blow he had hoped for, but Edmund could not hope to recapture the whole of England with only Wessex on his side. So, after the battle, they agreed to a peace deal. Edmund would retain Wessex, while Cnut would control the rest of the country. Edmund would also retain the crown. However, when one of them died, the other would take control of the whole country, and their children would have a guaranteed succession.

This deal was clearly unsustainable, a pause to allow both sides to lick their wounds and prepare for future struggle. And then suddenly, Edmund Ironside died, on St Andrews Day 1016. Whether he was murdered, ill, or succumbed to injuries from Assandun, we don't know. But Cnut was now the undisputed master of England. The Vikings had finally won. The old Anglo-Saxon royal family fled into exile. And for his treachery, Eadric was executed by Cnut in 1017.

However, this Viking Conquest of England was not to last. After Cnut, his two sons had short reigns, and died childless. By 1042, the Witan were looking for a new King. Who better than the brother of Edmund Ironside, Edward the Confessor?

Seemingly, the Danish Conquest of England had no long term impact. Unlike 1066, 1016 was not a Year 0. The Vikings took over the top tier of English society, but did not replace the entire ruling classes and structures, as the Normans would do.

But the Danish Conquest did have one major long term impact. As Cnut assumed power, the children of Aethelred fled overseas, into the safe care of their uncle. This alliance with the Duke of Normandy may have kept Edward the Confessor safe for a while, but it would ultimately bring about the end of Anglo-Saxon England.

Friday, 14 October 2016

The Battle of Hastings: The End of Days

Then Duke William sailed from Normandy into Pevensey, on the eve of Michaelmas. As soon as his men were fit for service, they constructed a castle at Hastings. When King Harold was informed of this, he gathered together a great host, and came to oppose him at the grey apple-tree, and William came upon him unexpectedly before his army was set in order. Nevertheless the King fought against him most resolutely with those men who wished to stand by him, and there was a great slaughter on both sides. King Harold was slain, and Leofwine, his brother, and Earl Gurth, his brother, and many good men. The French had possession of the place of slaughter, as God granted them because of the nation's sins.

950 years ago today, a period of history came to an end. It did so on a ridge-line in the Sussex countryside. The historical epoch shifted at dusk, although the struggle to end it had been going on since 9am. On this day, October 14th 1066, Anglo-Saxon England died on the battlefield of Senlac Hill. It would be known in the future as the Battle of Hastings.

The Battle of Hastings was a clash between two completely different worlds. Standing on the ridge that autumn morning, blocking the road to London, was the old world. The Anglo-Saxons represented a link to the end of the Roman Empire, with the barbarian migrations stemming from the vacuum left by the absence of Imperial power in the West. Their culture stretched back into the mists and forests of Northern Europe, a world inhabited by Beowulf, Woden and Thor. Upon settling in the British Isles, the Anglo-Saxons had soon adopted Christianity, and this blend of cultures had produced one of the intellectual and cultural powerhouses of the early medieval period.

Their recent past had been shaped by the Vikings. The Viking onslaught against the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms in the 800s had transformed the map of the British Isles forever. Before, there had been four Anglo-Saxon kingdoms, with power finely balanced between them. But in the middle of the ninth century, the Vikings had destroyed the kingdoms of East Anglia and Northumbria, and reduced Mercia to a shadow of its former glory. Only Wessex survived, with Alfred the Great coming back from seemingly certain catastrophe to overcome the Norsemen. Under his descendants, the West Saxons expanded their power into the rest of the British Isles, until by the middle of the 900s, a powerful, centralised, and fairly unified state had been created in the lowlands of Britain. It was originally called the kingdom of the Anglo-Saxons, but by 1066 it was widely known as the kingdom of the English.

Their new king, Harold II, was not of the ancient line of Cerdic of Wessex. Instead, he had been elected by the Witan, the council that advised and chose the king, to take control of the country after the old king, Edward the Confessor, had died childless. Harold and his men had just won a stunning victory at Stamford Bridge. They had crushed the invading forces of Harald Hardraada of Norway; although they did not know it at the time, but this marked the end of the Viking threat to England. Now they were facing yet another foe.

Strangely, though, this foe at the bottom of the hill, the Normans, had recently been a part of this world too. Their forefathers had also been Vikings, who had settled in Normandy a century or so earlier. But now they were ingrained into the domestic squabbles of the French monarchy. The Duke of Normandy had emerged as one of the leading French noblemen, wielding more power than the king of France. Quite impressive, given that William the Bastard had become Duke at the age of 7 or 8, and had been forced to claw back his control over the Duchy. He had expanded his power and influence. With Edward the Confessor dying, William pushed his distant claim to the English throne. An unruly band of French knights and lords had been assembled, and promised land and power if they participated in William's great English enterprise.

For much of that day in October 1066, it looked as if William's throw of the dice had failed. His early cavalry charges failed to penetrate the Anglo-Saxon shield wall. False retreats by the Normans did thin the English forces somewhat, as the knights cut down those Anglo-Saxons foolish enough to chase their foes. But it was not enough. All the Saxons had to do was hold firm until night. After that, they could bring up fresh forces and supplies. William, on the other hand, was trapped in a foreign country, with no easy means of supply or retreat, and dubious allies.

And then late in the day, it all went wrong for the Anglo-Saxons. Their warrior king, Harold, was slain. In the popular imagination, he took an arrow to the eye. Other sources say he was hacked to pieces. We simply don't know. But without him, the English army began to collapse. The slaughter was terrible. The Anglo-Saxon nobility, with many of them holding positions and titles that were centuries old, was destroyed on Senlac Hill. The rest of the army fled, or was killed.

William initially refused the English permission to bury their dead; the bodies rotted on the field where they had fallen. In a way, it was a metaphor for what was unfolding. Great change was on the way, as the Norman Conquest used the strong, centralised state to launch a revolution in England. The Normans were the masters now. The new world was displacing the old. At Hastings, nine and a half centuries ago today, Anglo-Saxon England had come to a sudden, bloody, and tragic end.

Saturday, 24 September 2016

Jeremy Corbyn, Episode II: Clone of the Result

What an utter waste of everybody's time. The Labour leadership election has resulted in another win for Jeremy Corbyn, who has slightly increased his lead, from 59% to 62%.

It's safe to say that Labour has had an utterly horrendous year. Electorally, it hasn't been great. Poor local election results in England, mediocre Welsh Assembly results, and a rout in the Scottish Parliament. And then over a quarter of a century of Labour foreign policy went up in smoke, as the British people voted to leave the EU.

This was the final straw for Labour MPs, who mounted a bid to oust Corbyn. First of all they no-confidenced him, which had... no effect. Next they tried to get him removed from the ballot in the leadership race... with similar results. And their final chance to get rid of him went wrong the moment they picked Owen Smith as their challenger. The internal debate has dragged on for months, with horrific abuse being hurled by both sides of the divide. For those of us who care about left wing politics, it has been like watching someone self-harm in public.

And all this pain and effort was for virtually nothing. Corbyn retained the leadership, by virtually the same margin as before. All that self-destruction was for nothing.

Despite all his cries of victory, things were not all plain sailing for Corbyn. He actually lost amongst the members who voted for him last year, by an impressive 63:37. His victory rested on the huge swell of new members he has brought into the party in the intervening twelve months. Owen Smith, for all he was a horrendous candidate, actually polled better than any of the leadership candidates last year, or indeed Ed Miliband in 2010.

But regardless of all that, this has to stop. Over the last year, the government has governed virtually unopposed. Labour's war with itself has not solved the problems in the party, it has only made them worse. And it has enabled the government to make the lives of millions of people worse. The Official Opposition has a job to do. It needs to start doing it.

It is now clear that, shy of a landslide defeat in a snap election, Jeremy Corbyn will remain as Labour leader until 2020. So, a truce is essential. The Labour MPs, the longer-term party members, and those towards the centre of the political spectrum, need to recognise that Jeremy Corbyn has tapped into a powerful reservoir of left wing support and enthusiasm. Fighting it has not worked. Indeed, much of their anger is justified, and should be what Labour is trying to address. Instead of trying to fight it, they need to find a way to work alongside it. It may offer a road back into government, no matter how remote that chance seems. Even if it doesn't, the centrists and moderates need to find a way to work alongside those people whose anger at the status quo is justified, and can be harnessed. Defections and splits may seem attractive, but they will make things worse, not better. When the SDP left Labour in the 1980s, they did not 'break the mould,' they let Mrs Thatcher back into government. Twice. Splitting the vote and letting the Tories back in will not help any Labour supporters, or Labour voters.

In return, the Corbynites need to accept that they are in control of the only left-wing political force in the United Kingdom that is in a position of assuming national power. This puts an enormous responsibility on them. Millions upon millions of people who need or want a left-wing government are relying on them to make it a reality. This means winning a general election. Everything they do must now be devoted to that aim. Preferring social movements and extra-parliamentary action is fine. But it is not what they are in control of. They are in control of a political party committed to the democratic road to power. True social progress is made not with the banner but with the ballot box. Those around Jeremy Corbyn are being tasked with delivering the next left-wing government. They must never forget that, nor act in a way that harms that.

Overall, the Labour party needs to accept it is a broad church. It contains a wide range of opinions and views. Ever since 1900, it has represented a coalition of interests. Indeed, it must be a broad based movement, to enable it to speak on behalf of all the people. So all the abuse, all the insults, threats, and derogatory remarks have to stop. Both sides have stooped to these levels in their struggle for control of the party. But the sexism, the racial slurs, the appalling anti-Semitism, the resurrection of political insults from different decades, the attacks on constituency surgeries, the threats of de-selection and sacking, have to stop. The people are watching. If you are seen as a repository for hate, they will not trust you with control of the country. And if you want to see where political hate can end up, the seat next door to mine is holding a by-election soon, to replace an MP shot dead in the streets.

If the two wings of the Labour party do not unite, then they will be destroyed at the next election. If they try to come together, there is just a small chance they will survive as a political force, and one day will operate the levers of power in the name of those who cannot speak up for themselves. Unite or die.

Saturday, 17 September 2016

Why we are all still living in 1991

As a quick glance at this blog will confirm, I'm a big fan of historical anniversaries. This year, I've noticed that there have been a whole host of 25th anniversaries. More interestingly, many of the events of 1991 seem to have a direct relevance for us today.

L.P. Hartley told us that the past is a foreign country, and that they do things differently there. The recent past is a strangely alien place, at once almost familiar and yet so very different. But in 1991, they weren't doing things that differently to us after all.

Gulf War

It was billed as the first war of the New World Order- a rogue state was fought by a coalition, under a UN mandate, to ensure that international justice was maintained. The war was fought with smart weapons, helping to ensure that casualties were kept to a minimum. The war was fought to the letter of the UN's authorisation, and not a moment longer.

This is all a bit neat. In reality, the high-tech violence unleashed against Iraq by the US-led coalition in 1991 was utterly brutal. Civilians were killed. The Atlantic Alliance had spent the last half a century devising weapons designed to be used in a final struggle with the Eastern Bloc. When these weapons were finally used, they turned out to be devastating. There are accounts of bodies melting and pooling as fat in facilities hit by the bombing. The Iraqi army was so weakened that, when the invasion came, the land war lasted only 100 hours. There are serious questions as to whether or not such disproportionate use of force constituted a war crime.

The Gulf War of 1991 still stands as an excellent example of multilateralism. George Bush Senior put together a very impressive coalition of diverse countries, under a UN banner, to maintain international order. They did the job the UN had given them, and then they went home.

But, the longer term effects cast a much darker shadow. The Gulf War marked a transitional point. Saddam Hussein's Iraq had been an ally of the West during the 1980s, a counterpoint against the Iranians. Now Saddam was an enemy. His actions were the concerns of the rest of the world. The road to 2003 was already open, even if it wasn't yet clear.

And, barely discernible at the time, it put the USA in serious danger. When Iraq first invaded Kuwait, the Saudi monarchy received an offer from a leader of the mujahideen, the Islamic-inspired rebels who had just fought the USSR in Afghanistan. He offered his men to defend the holy sites in Saudi Arabia, and expel Iraq from Kuwait. That way, no non-Muslims would set foot in the sacred lands of the Prophet. The Saudis, faced with this rabble or the world's sole remaining superpower, chose the USA. The mujahideen leader was outraged, and directed his anger at America. His name? Osama bin Laden.

Iraqi vehicles destroyed along the Highway of Death by Allied airstrikes


Uprisings Against Saddam

If the Gulf War was an example of multilateralism at its finest, then the actions of the world in the aftermath of the war are less good. With his armed forces shattered, and his authority severely reduced, Saddam was gravely weakened by the Gulf War. For those inside Iraq who had suffered during his reign, they saw this as their best chance to overthrow the wretched dictator who had made their lives a misery. Egged on by the Voice of America radio broadcasts, a strange collection of Shia Arabs, Kurds, left-wing dissidents, and disillusioned soldiers, all rose in revolt against Saddam.

At first it seemed like they had succeeded. Within a few days, the Iraqi government controlled only four of Iraq's 18 regions. Millions of Iraqis had abandoned the regime; even Saddam's secret police fired their weapons in joy at his presumed overthrow.

Saddam may have been down, but he was not out. The deal with the UN forces that had ended the Gulf War enabled the Iraqis to continue using helicopters. Officially, this was to transport personnel around, given that the Allied air attacks had crippled Iraq's ground infrastructure. But Saddam used those same helicopters to suppress the rebellions. He unleashed his crack Republican Guard troops against the rebels, crushing first the Shia, then the Marsh Arabs, before finally turning on the Kurds.

The Kurds were terrified; it was only three years since Saddam had killed 5000 Kurds with chemical weapons, at Halabja. Pretty much the entire population of Kurdistan fled into the mountains, and the peshmerga prepared to make a final stand against the advancing Iraqi army.

It never came. The West belatedly realised what it had done, and, under pressure from the UK, created no fly zones in northern and southern Iraq. The Kurds were saved, and ultimately created a stable, prosperous and democratic autonomous region.

But for the rest of Iraq, the uprisings cost them dear. Thousands were killed as Saddam reimposed control, and the ancient way of life of the Marsh Arabs was ended forever, with the draining of the marshes.

The Iraqi people took a clear message; the rest of the world was not interested in helping to rescue them from Saddam. So when in 2003, the Americans and British rolled in yet again, the population was not grateful. They remembered how the West had abandoned them in their hour of need. We are still reaping the effects of failing to depose Saddam when the Iraqis wanted, rather than when George W Bush wanted.

Iraqi Kurds fleeing into the mountains

Maastricht Treaty

In the winter of 1991, the leaders of the European Community went to the Dutch town of Maastricht. They were there to discuss fundamental changes to the institution that they belonged to. Since it's foundation in the 1950s, the EC had been focused primarily on economic integration. There were some political structures, such as the European Parliament. But it was primarily to do with trade. Not for nothing was it known in English as the Common Market.

At Maastricht, all that changed. The document which emerged from that meeting was the Treaty on European Union. It set out plans for the creation of a single European currency, and committed the signatories to work together to develop common approaches to law enforcement, foreign policy, criminal justice, and social policy. What emerged from Maastricht was the EU that, for better or for worse, we all know today.

Even at the time, there was a recognition by the UK government that this would not go down well with British voters. And so John Major, in an incredible bit of negotiating, was able to secure a UK opt-out from the single currency, and to make the social affairs part an entirely separate agreement, which the UK then refused to sign. But this was not enough. Getting the Treaty ratified in Parliament nearly destroyed the Conservative Party, and it looks years to recover in the eyes of the voters. But above all, Maastricht made the issue of Euroscepticism a mainstream, acceptable opinion in the UK. A host of groups emerged to oppose the Treaty. One, the Anti-Federalist League, later morphed into UKIP. Had the Conservative party not chosen to endorse the Treaty, maybe the young Nigel Farage would never have quit the party in favour of the AFL.

The EU as we know it was created in Maastricht in December 1991, but the seeds of Brexit were planted as well.

BBC News, during the Maastricht summit, Dec 1991


End of the USSR

I've already discussed this here, so I won't go into it too much. Anyway, it was the fall of the Berlin Wall, in November 1989, that marked the real end of the Cold War, and which ushered in the era of American geopolitical dominance that we are still living in (debatable, see below). But for neatness sake, the end of the Soviet Union should probably get a look in.


Rodney King arrest


It must have seemed like any other crime committed that night. Late on the evening of March 3rd, 1991, the California Highway Patrol tried to stop a vehicle. When the car failed to stop, police gave chase, at speeds of up to 115mph. When the car was eventually stopped, the occupants were arrested.

What happened next shocked the United States. The last man out of the car was the driver, Rodney King. He was tasered, and repeatedly beaten by five LAPD officers, even after he had clearly ceased to be any kind of threat. The entire incident was captured on a camcorder. The officers claimed that they believed King to be on PCP, but no trace of it was ever detected, and his behaviour didn't fit this claim. Even amongst law enforcement officers, there was outrage at the behaviour of the police.

In April 1992, the police officers were acquitted on charges of assault. This was the cue for an outbreak of severe rioting in Los Angeles. Over five days and nights, a total of 55 people died, as rioting, looting, and fire fights engulfed Los Angeles. 2000 people were injured, and more than 11,000 were injured. In desperation, the California National Guard, and parts of the regular US Army, were deployed on the streets to restore law and order.

In terms of civil rights, we have come a long way. But the Rodney King beatings, and subsequent riots, show just as clearly as Ferguson and all the other tragedies that we still have a long way to go.

Footage from the arrest of Rodney King


World Wide Web goes public

Tim Berners-Lee deserves that knighthood. In 1991, he transformed the world we lived in forever. Over the past decade, Berners-Lee, who worked at CERN, had been designing and building "a large hypertext database with typed links." By late 1990, he had built an internal version at CERN. And in January 1991, the first Web servers outside of CERN were switched on.

This was not the start of the internet; that had been in existence since the late 1960s. What Tim Berners-Lee was offering was a brand new interface for presenting, storing and accessing information on the internet. One of the early name proposals for the World Wide Web was The Information Mine. Which gives you a pretty good idea of what they were going for.

Pretty much every single way you interact with the internet is through the World Wide Web, from checking your bank account, checking Facebook, emails (often, I will give you this is the last major exception), checking the news, even reading this post.

In future, when historians look back at our age, I reckon they will focus on this moment as one of the major turning points in history. We cannot now go back to a Webless world. The world as it existed before January 1991 is gone forever, separated from us by the colossus of the World Wide Web.

First ever web server, located at CERN


Birmingham Six released

Terrorism is a horrific thing. It kills and maims indiscriminately. It brings fear and panic to the society that it seeks to undermine. It turns the state against its citizens, and people against each other.

On November 21st 1974, between 20:15 and 20:30, 21 people were murdered in Birmingham, when bombs detonated in two pubs in the city centre. 182 people were badly injured. In terms of fatalities, it was the worst attack on mainland Britain during the Troubles. The police had received a coded warning from the Provisional IRA, but it was far too vague, and far too late.

The police had an early breakthrough. Six men, all known to an IRA member who had died trying to plant a bomb in Coventry earlier in the year, were all arrested trying to leave Birmingham not long after the attacks. They were all Northern Irish, all Roman Catholic, and were actually travelling to the funeral of the man who had died in Coventry, a fact they did not mention to the police who questioned them in Morecambe. In 1975, they were all convicted on 21 counts of murder, and sentenced to life imprisonment.

The problem was, they were innocent. All six had been subject to threats, beatings, threatened with dogs, and in one case forced into a mock execution. Under these circumstances, some had signed statements which had been written for them. The forensic evidence that they had handled explosives was extremely shaky.

As soon as they were imprisoned, the Birmingham Six began a long fight to clear their names. Their first attempt to appeal was rejected. In 1985, ITV's World in Action broadcast a documentary which seriously challenged the case against the men; as World in Action's Chris Mullin, later a Labour MP, claimed to have spoken to the actual bombers, it hardly seemed likely that the right people were in prison. Amazingly, this was not enough for the Court of Appeal, and in 1988 the men's convictions were upheld.

But the cat was out of the bag, and over the next three years momentum built behind the campaign to free the men. Eventually, in 1991 the case went back to the Court of Appeal. The Crown made the unprecedented step of not opposing the appeal, as it realised the convictions were clearly unsafe. The judges ruled that the men were free to leave.

As a result of this, and similar appalling miscarriages of justice, a Royal Commission was setup, which recommended the creation the Criminal Cases Review Commission, to examine convictions and appeals. But that is why this is not a significant moment.

The enduring significance of this event, and those like it, is the realisation that terrorism is a challenge we cannot get wrong. Six men, whose only crime was to have known a person who had broken the law, had spent 16 years in prison. But that reasoning, I know people who should be in prison. Myself included. They had been failed by the police and the judiciary. As they languished in their cells, the IRA's West Midlands unit was free to continue its attacks. And the trust between citizens and the state, which is crucial to defeat terrorism, was undermined, at least for some.

Today, we face the same challenges. There have been calls to give more powers to the Security Services to intrude on our lives, to allow longer detention without trial, to allow evidence and even whole trials to be heard in secret, or without a jury. Will that really help make us safer? In 1991, the answer was clear for all to see.

The Birmingham Six, along with MP Chris Mullin, outside the Court of Appeal after their convictions were overturned


Premier League is launched

Before 1991, if you'd used the words 'Premier League', people would have given you a strange look. Was it a type of beer?

English football was in a bit of a nadir in the early 1990s. The 1980s had seen the game blighted by hooliganism, falling attendances, static revenues. Many top players were moving abroad. What was even worse, in the eyes of the best clubs at least, was that the money acquired for the television broadcasts of the First Division was split evenly across the Football League.

As the 1991 season drew to a close, the five top clubs in the First Division (Arsenal, Manchester United, Spurs, Liverpool, and Everton) pounced. They signed an agreement that, after one more season of the Football League, they would break away and create a 'Premier League.' This was billed as an attempt to improve the quality of football, both in the top flight, and for the national team. The clubs in this Premier League would be able to keep all of the money from TV to themselves, instead of having to share it with clubs that no one had ever heard of.

In some respects, the Premier League succeeded spectacularly. The amount of money in football has increased dramatically, with clubs regularly trading players for hundreds of millions of pounds. Fit, young adults are now paid hundreds of thousands of pounds a week. People who had been stars beforehand were transformed into superstars, celebrities, whose actions off the pitch were as closely followed as those on it. At the same time, football was becoming more acceptable again. A game which had been associated with the working classes, and with violence, was being gentrified. Attendances rose, and so did ticket prices. Foreign investors became attracted at the sponsorship and ownership possibilities of English clubs. Soon, even previously minor English clubs had followers across the world, all supporting their favourite local Manchester United.

But, the much vaunted improvement in national football never followed. The English team continues to be the source of many jokes. Neither did it do much good for the teams that resigned en masse from the First Division; only nine of them are still in the Premier League (at the time of writing), and four of them have sunk to the third tier of English football.

Without the Premier League, most of this would doubtless have happened. But the cult of elite football was cemented by that decision.

The 1992-93 Premier League teams


US Presidential Longshot Bid Announced

Finally, it was in the autumn of 1991 that speculation began in earnest for the US presidential election in 1992. For the Republicans, their candidate was easy. George Bush had sky-high approval ratings over his handling of the Gulf War and the end of the Cold War.

This had an effect on the Democrats too. With Bush seemingly a shoo in for a second term, many high profile Democrats chose to bide their time. By 1996, the Republicans would have controlled the White House for 15 years. Whoever emerged as Bush's successor would be much easier to defeat. This meant that big names such as Mario Cuomo and Al Gore decided to sit the race out. But some decided to give it a shot in 1992. They were generally perceived as second rate candidates, people no one had heard of, who were entering to give the appearance of a contest.

One such man announced his bid in October 1991. There was little in his favour. He was the governor of a tiny Southern state, which hadn't voted for a Democratic presidential candidate since 1976. He'd been in office there since 1979, with two years out; he was actually the Southern governor mentioned in Jimmy Carter's malaise speech. He'd given the keynote address to the 1988 Democratic convention. It had been long, rambling, and bored many delegates. When he finally said 'In conclusion,' he got a round of cheers. The governor was going to have been a candidate himself in 1988. However, at the last minute, he withdrew. Rumours swirled that his personal life contained past affairs and mistresses that would sink his candidacy.

But in 1991, Bill Clinton threw himself into the race many said he would never win. One of his biggest supporters, and best advisers, was his wife. Back in 2016, she is now a stone's throw away from sitting in the Oval Office herself. Truly, we are still living in 1991.

Hillary, Chelsea and Bill Clinton, as he announced his bid for the White House, October 1991

Sunday, 11 September 2016

Fifteen Years On From September 11th

For in the final analysis, our most basic common link is that we all inhabit this small planet. We all breathe the same air. We all cherish our children's futures. And we are all mortal
John F Kennedy, June 1963

It is a decade and a half since barbarity struck on September 11th 2001. Hijacked aeroplanes were used as weapons, striking at the symbols of American power in the early 21st century. The twin skyscrapers of the World Trade Centre, the centre of American economic might, were brought to the ground. The Pentagon, the ultimate symbol of the military supremacy of the Pax Americana, was left with a gaping hole. A fourth airliner came down in a field in the countryside, as the hostages and crew fought a last ditch battle to regain control of the aircraft. Nearly three thousand people were killed.

I was 11. I'd been at school all day. My mum had come to pick me up, halfway home, as per usual. The person that told me was my brother. When we got home, we put the TV on. I can't remember much after that. It's hard to separate what you saw from what you later knew had happened. But even at the age of eleven, you know these things are major. I remember the numb shock. The stunned shock at the appalling violence, at the slaughter of countless people. If I felt that at 11, Lord knows what people felt as adults.

What I didn't realise at the time was the unanimity of this reaction. In the fifteen years since, it is nearly impossible to recall or imagine the range of nations and groups that rallied around the people of the United States of America. The response of America's allies, the democracies of the Western world, was one of grief, shock, and offerings of support. More telling were the public shows of solidarity. In Belgium, a chain of people held hands around the Belgian World Trade Centre. In the UK, the guards outside Buckingham Palace played the American national anthem, and for the only time ever, the BBC's Last Night of the Proms did not close with God Save the Queen, instead fading out to The Star-Spangled Banner. Everywhere, there was public mourning, rallies and moments of silence. I remember our school holding a minute's silence.

More surprising was the outpouring of support from elsewhere in the world. Countries which have spent years pitted against America were offering comfort and support. Russia and China, America's old and new foes, were shocked, and there were scenes of genuine grief on the streets. Cuba, which languished for 50 years under American sanctions, offered medical facilities to help treat the injured. In Iran, a country which still describes America as the Great Satan, the president and the Ayatollah condemned the violence. The next international football match was marked by a two minute silence, there was a candlelit vigil in Tehran. North Korea sent its condolences. Colonel Gaddafi, whose Libyan intelligence agencies had carried out terrorist attacks against American targets in the 1980s, condemned the attacks. Even the Taliban government of Afghanistan sent their condolences, and they were sheltering the culprit. In fact, only one country broke this show of unity, and that was Saddam Hussein's Iraq.

Candlelit vigil in Tehran, September 18th, 2001

But it wasn't just countries. The UN Security Council pledged to do all it could to uphold the United Nations Charter in the aftermath of the carnage. Religious leaders of every faith denounced the shedding of innocent blood in their sermons. Groups which are classified by the West as terrorist organisations lined up to denounce the attack, such as Hezbollah, the PLO, and Hamas.

I can't think of anything, before or since, that has united such a diverse range of interests and groups, who were often at each other's throats. Unfortunately, the years since have not seen this alliance maintained. George W Bush, for whatever reason, decided to attack Iraq in 2003, destabilising the Middle East, wrecking the country, and squandering nearly all of that goodwill. But, however briefly, we saw how the world could be different, and that, deep down, there is a way to unite us all.

Today we should remember the 2996 people who died on that awful September morning, fifteen years ago. The best way we can honour their memory is to strive to recreate the world that existed as the sun set on September 11th, 2001, when the world spoke with almost one voice, to show their shock and their anger, and to pledge support for people they had never met.

I think the last words go to Jon Stewart.

Sunday, 4 September 2016

The Wit and Wisdom of... Jo Grimond

In bygone days, commanders were taught that when in doubt, they should march their troops towards the sound of gunfire. I intend to march my troops towards the sound of gunfire.

Jo Grimond, Liberal Party leader, addressing the Liberal Party Assembly, 16th September 1963